Internal Instability of Cohesionless Soils in Upward and Downward Flow: An Experimental Verification of Theory

Rigid-wall permeameter testing of two potentially unstable gradations established the critical hydraulic gradient to trigger instability is smaller for upward flow than for downward flow. The experimental finding is explained with reference to the Skempton-Brogan stress reduction factor α in the finer fraction content of the soil. Theory uses the α-factor to define a hydro-mechanical envelope in gradient-stress space that is independent of flow direction, and the experimental results are found in good agreement with the theory. Testing with upward flow is recommended to determine the value of α for an internally unstable gradation because, in contrast to downward flow, there is no requirement for an outflow boundary.