Who Killed the Mobility Hub? Parking Pricing, Access Conditions, and Mode Choice at Rome Trastevere
Francesco Cuccaro, Rodrigo Tapia, Valerio Gatta, Edoardo MarcucciMobility hubs promise to reduce car dependence and make multimodal travel work in practice, yet behavioural evidence remains limited when hub improvements coexist with easier car access. This article examines the tension at Rome Trastevere, an urban rail node that gradually acquires mobility-hub functions while facing improved parking access near Piazza della Radio. The empirical analysis combines a pilot survey of 83 users with an on-site stated preference survey of 204 valid respondents. The stated preference instrument uses a route-based feasible-choice design with nine choice sets per experiment: respondents evaluate alternatives among bikes, walking, e-scooters, e-mopeds, public transport, private cars, and shared cars under variations in travel time, travel cost, and search time. The paper estimates a multinomial logit model in Apollo and uses sample enumeration, supported by Monte Carlo simulation, to assess four parking and shared-mobility scenarios and produce confidence intervals around predicted probabilities. Results show that users respond to time, monetary cost, and search friction in coherent and policy-relevant ways. Setting the car parking search time to zero increases predicted car probability only marginally, by about 0.9% relative to the baseline. By contrast, a EUR 1/h increase in parking cost reduces predicted car probability by about 14.7%, while a EUR 1.5/h increase reduces it by about 22.4%. A coordinated scenario combining higher parking cost and lower shared-mode search time produces the lowest predicted car probability and strengthens e-scooter and e-moped alternatives, while public transport remains the dominant option. Findings indicate that parking pricing steers behaviour more clearly than parking convenience destabilizes it in the tested range. The paper shows that mobility-hub performance depends on coordinated access management, including parking regulation, shared-service reliability, and legible multimodal transfer.