WERF Endometriosis Phenome and Biobanking Harmonisation Project for Experimental Models in Endometriosis Research (EPHect-EM-Homologous): homologous rodent models
Katherine A Burns, Daniëlle Peterse, Caroline B Appleyard, Ronald Chandler, Sun-Wei Guo, Amelia Pearson, Eleonora Persoons, Michael S Anglesio, Michael S Rogers, Kathy L Sharpe-Timms, Joris Vriens, Stacey L McAllister, Kelsi N Dodds, Fiona L Cousins, Lone Hummelshoj, Stacey A Missmer, Kaylon L Bruner-Tran, Erin Greaves, , Nick A Andrews, Michael S Anglesio, Caroline B Appleyard, Joe Arosh, Christian M Becker, Kaylon L Bruner-Tran, Katherine A Burns, Ronald L Chandler, Julie A Christianson, Fiona L Cousins, Kelsi N Dodds, Victor Fattori, Asgi Fazleabas, Caroline Gargett, Juan S Gnecco, Raul Gomez, Martin Götte, Erin Greaves, Linda G Griffith, Patrick G Groothuis, Ruth Grümmer, Sun-Wei Guo, Shannon M Hawkins, M Louise Hull, Lone Hummelshoj, Mark Hutchinson, Mohamed Gamal Ibrahim, Elizabeth E Marr, Stacy L McAllister, Stacey A Missmer, Jeffrey Mogill, Jens Nagel, Warren B Nothnick, Paulina Nunez-Badinez, Kevin G Osteen, Daniëlle Peterse, Michael S Rogers, Andrea Romano, Philippa T K Saunders, Miguel Ángel Tejada, Kathy L Sharpe-Timms, Waldiceu A Verri, Paola Viganó, Katy VincentAbstract
In vivo models of endometriosis enable the discovery and preclinical testing of new therapies. Several rodent models of endometriosis exist, but a lack of harmonization impedes reproducibility and comparability of results among investigators. Homologous models are advantageous as they allow the contribution of the immune system/inflammation to be studied. We reviewed published homologous rodent models of endometriosis to develop standard operating procedures (‘EPHect-EM-Homologous-SOPs’) to guide and facilitate the choice and implementation of these models and harmonize documentation to enhance interpretation and comparability of results. The World Endometriosis Research Foundation (WERF) established an international working group of experts in models of endometriosis and formed a working sub-group to discuss homologous rodent models of endometriosis. A systematic literature review and detailed analysis of protocols was performed. The identified models have advantages and limitations regarding physiological relevance and utility. To harmonize key variables for endometriosis rodent models, the working group focused on species and animal strains, placement of ectopic tissue, uterine tissue volume, method of induction, hormonal status, and uterine tissue ‘type’. A decision tree and recommendations on model use were developed for mice and rats to serve as guides for the use of harmonized EPHect-EM-Homologous-SOPs, experimental design, reporting standards, and research of question-dependent key variables. No ‘ideal’ homologous model of endometriosis was identified. The choice of model for specific research should be guided according to a best-fit strategy. Harmonization of SOPs, documentation, and reporting standards will improve replicability and translational applicability of studies and better highlight where de novo model creation is needed.