Toward environmentally efficient orthodontic imaging: assessing JPEG compression effects on automated artificial intelligence and manual cephalometric analysis
Sertaç Aksakallı, Halit Hami Öz, Erhan Demir, İrem AydınAbstract
Objective
This study evaluates the impact of various JPEG compression levels (1.0, 0.8, 0.5, and 0.3) on the stability and accuracy of cephalometric analyses performed by a manual expert and three commercial AI (artificial intelligence) software packages (CranioCatch, CEPHX, and WEBCEPH).
Materials and Methods
Forty digital lateral cephalometric radiographs were compressed into four quality levels using a standardized web application (ImageMagick v7.1.0). A total of 10 measurements, categorized into skeletal, dental, and soft-tissue parameters, were analyzed. Measurement stability was assessed using the Friedman test, while agreement with the manual reference standard was evaluated using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and mean absolute error.
Results
Stability was maintained across most parameters up to the 0.3 compression level (70% quality reduction) (P > .05). Significant discrepancies were found between AI engines relative to the manual standard. The highest variation occurred in the Nasolabial angle, with a 20.95° difference between the manual expert and WEBCEPH. Baseline agreement with the manual standard ranged from low to excellent across parameters (ICC 0.50–0.96), with the highest agreement for interincisal angle and U1/SN, and the lowest for SNA, nasolabial angle, and U1 to NA (mm). While skeletal parameters showed high inter-software consistency, soft-tissue and dental inclination assessments revealed a significant lack of standardization.
Conclusion
High JPEG compression (down to 0.3) produced no clinically meaningful measurement changes in high-quality radiographs, providing a 70%–80% file size reduction supporting “Green Radiology” goals. However, baseline diagnostic variations between AI platforms necessitate consistent single-software use for longitudinal tracking.