Sustainable Roofing in Hot Climates: A Comparative Lifecycle Assessment of Residential Buildings in Saudi Arabia

Roofing systems strongly influence the energy performance and environmental footprint of buildings, particularly in hot–arid climates such as Saudi Arabia, where cooling dominates electricity demand; however, the comparative lifecycle environmental performance of alternative roofing strategies remains underexplored in this specific climatic and market context. This study therefore aims to evaluate and compare the environmental performance of four sustainable roofing strategies against a conventional flat roof (FR) baseline in order to provide evidence-based guidance for climate-specific roofing selection in Saudi Arabia. This study conducts a comparative cradle-to-grave lifecycle assessment (LCA) of four sustainable roofing strategies considering the hot–arid climate of Saudi Arabia. Green roof (GR), cool roof (CR), solar photovoltaic roof (SPV), and roof canopy (RC) were assessed using the ReCiPe 2016 method in the SimaPro software. The environmental impacts of these strategies were assessed across product, construction, use, and end-of-life stages relative to conventional flat roofs (FRs). The results indicate that the production stage consistently contributes the highest environmental impacts, with increases ranging from 30 to 3000% for GR, CR, and RC and exceeding 10,000% for SPV. On the other hand, the use stage offers the greatest reductions ranging from 10 to 200%, particularly for SPV and CR, due to operational energy savings and electricity generation. Overall, CR demonstrates the most balanced environmental performance, combining high impact reductions with minimal trade-offs, while SPV provides significant climate and fossil resource benefits but increases mineral resource use. These findings highlight the importance of climate-specific and resource-conscious selection of roofing strategies in Saudi Arabia and provide a transferable comparative LCA framework that can inform sustainable roofing decisions in other hot–arid and hot–humid regions, in support of the Kingdom’s Vision 2030 objectives for sustainable urban development.