Quantum Autoencoders for Network Anomaly Detection: A Comparative Benchmark with Classical Methods

The practical value of quantum machine learning for network anomaly detection remains unclear under controlled and comparable benchmarking conditions. This study evaluates a trash-qubit-based Quantum Autoencoder (QAE) against seven classical anomaly-detection methods on UNSW-NB15 using shared data partitions, preprocessing steps, model selection procedures, and threshold calibration protocols. The experimental design included five independent seeds, three training set sizes, two feature budgets, and 12 QAE architectures, together with low-FPR analysis, finite-shot and synthetic-noise evaluation, less-constrained classical reference settings, and a cross-dataset assessment on TON_IoT. The Angle-RY encoding with a Real-Amplitudes Ring ansatz at depth L = 2 achieved the highest mean validation-selection AUPRC. On UNSW-NB15, the QAE was competitive in AUPRC and AUROC but remained behind the strongest classical baselines in F1-score, and its attack recall declined sharply under low-FPR constraints. The TON_IoT results further showed that relative model performance depended on the dataset. Under finite-shot and synthetic-noise conditions, anomaly-score rankings were largely preserved, whereas threshold-based decisions were more sensitive. Overall, the QAE showed competitive continuous-score discrimination on UNSW-NB15, but achieving reliable detection at low false-alarm rates remains a key operational challenge.