Paddy Ashdown’s Third Way: The Liberal Democrats and the Politics of the 1990s

Abstract

Existing accounts of policy change in 1990s Britain focus primarily on New Labour. Tony Blair’s 1994 election as Labour leader signaled a period of growing elite convergence around a post-industrial economic model, rule-based economic management, and the use of market mechanisms to achieve social objectives. For all Blair’s claims to novelty, however, his “third way” chimed closely with the policy agenda that Paddy Ashdown had developed as Liberal Democrat leader during the early 1990s. This article provides the first detailed analysis of Liberal Democrat policymaking under Ashdown’s leadership (1988–99) and seeks to clarify the party’s intellectual relationship with New Labour. It argues that the Liberal Democrats’ embrace of market economics between 1988 and 1992 marked an important step in the diffusion and entrenchment of neoliberal ideas across the UK political spectrum, and that Ashdown’s efforts to synthesize market liberalism with plans for constitutional reform, social investment, and decarbonization anticipated New Labour in important respects. By taking Ashdown’s policy work seriously, the article shows that his pursuit of a coalition with Blair was not merely a product of tactical considerations. Rather, Ashdown hoped that the two men could realign British politics around a shared vision of economic and political “modernization.”