Influence of Controlled Lighting Conditions on Smartphone-Based Augmented Reality Recognition of a 3D-Printed Dental Model for Implantological Applications

Smartphone-based augmented reality (AR) may help dentists visualize an implant axis during treatment or training. Before a virtual overlay can be displayed, however, the application must first recognize the real target reliably. This in vitro study tested how five lighting conditions affected recognition of a two-colored, 3D-printed polylactic acid (PLA) dental model by a Unity/Vuforia smartphone application. The application ran on a Samsung Galaxy S22. A GoPro HERO10 recorded the smartphone display at 240 frames per second, and the videos were evaluated frame by frame. Red, green, blue, daylight-like light-emitting diode (LED) and halogen illumination were tested at a central and an eccentric model position, with ten repetitions per condition and position. The model was not recognized under red or blue illumination within the predefined observation interval. Recognition was successful in all repetitions under green, daylight-like and halogen illumination. Recognition speed differed among these successful conditions, and the eccentric position delayed recognition under daylight-like and halogen illumination. A supplementary region-of-interest analysis also showed lighting-dependent differences in image brightness and contrast. These findings indicate that lighting should be standardized and documented when smartphone-based dental AR systems are developed and tested.