DOI: 10.69554/gnif5652 ISSN: 1749-9224

Icehotel or Wonderland? Reimagining the United States’ National Incident Management System

Lisa Wier, Tony Mcaleavy
Show PDF Cite
Disasters and catastrophes are increasing in frequency, severity and complexity, meaning that effective multi-organisational response has never been more pertinent. The United States’ National Incident Management System (NIMS), which includes the on-scene Incident Command System (ICS) component, is mandated for use at all levels of government and is often framed, somewhat narrowly, as a mechanistic hierarchy or an organic network. The related literature is divergent: academic critiques are lamented for lacking real-world insights whereas practitioner accounts are, unfairly, dismissed as anecdotal, meaning that novel insights that inform future preparedness are needed. Accordingly, this conceptual study reimagines NIMS/ICS using pragmatism, metaphorical analysis — informed by Morgan’s seminal organisational metaphors, Pinto’s ‘Icehotel’, and McCabe’s ‘Wonderland’ metaphors — and symbolic logic. This paper demonstrates that NIMS/ICS is both mechanistic and organic, and much more at the same time. They engender much-needed novel and innovative perspectives which can be embedded within training and education activities to address the increasingly complex nature of disasters and catastrophes.

More from our Archive