Deconstructing empirical fitness seascapes across scales of granularity

Abstract

The fitness landscape metaphor remains resonant in evolutionary theory and has facilitated the birth of newer concepts, like the fitness seascape, that consider the role of environmental context in shaping the dynamics of evolution. Since its emergence, the seascape has appeared in numerous studies examining how different and fluctuating environments shape evolutionary outcomes. Despite growing interest, we lack comprehensive examinations of how environmental context shapes features of fitness seascapes. In this study, we address this gap by deconstructing empirical fitness seascapes across scales of granularity: loci, locus interactions (epistasis), alleles, trajectories, and entire seascapes. For each, we examine how environmental context influences qualitative and quantitative aspects of seascapes, and find that they change appreciably, with patterns specific to individual systems of study. We also quantify how much each scale varies across environments, and find that certain scales tend to be more sensitive to context than others. In summary, we reflect on the implications of the seascape metaphor for the incorporation of environmental effects into theoretical population genetics, for understanding how the environment shapes evolution in disease systems, and for contemporary bioengineering efforts.