Comparative Life Cycle Assessment of Physical and Chemical Activation Routes for Oil Palm Shell-Derived Activated Carbon in Lufenuron 50-EC Pesticide Adsorption

This study evaluates the life cycle assessment (LCA) of Lufenuron 50-EC pesticide adsorption from aqueous solution using oil palm shell (OPS)-derived activated carbon produced through two activation routes: physical and chemical. The assessment covers environmental impacts associated with feedstock collection, transportation, pre-processing, and post-processing stages involved in producing activated carbon for pesticide removal. The cradle-to-grave LCA technique was applied using the ELCD 3.2 Greendelta v2.18 database and processed with OpenLCA v2.4 using CML-IA baseline method to perform the quantitative life cycle impact assessment. The results for treating 1 m3 of contaminated water show that physical activation route (Route 1) generates a higher environmental burden across all evaluated impact categories compared to chemical route (Route 2). Notably, global warming potential (GWP) reached 117.62 kg CO2 eq for Route 1 compared to 75.86 kg CO2 eq for Route 2. This represents a 35.5% reduction with the chemical route, suggesting that the high energy demand associated with thermal process in physical activation generates more significant greenhouse gas emissions. Overall, this study helped identify critical performance points and opportunities for improvement in converting the OPS to an activated carbon transformation process and its application in pesticide contamination control.