Comparative Assessment of Lead Rubber and Friction Pendulum Seismic Isolation Systems Under Varying Seismic Hazard and Site Conditions

This study investigates the comparative effectiveness of Lead Rubber Bearing (LRB) and Friction Pendulum System (FPS) isolation units under varying seismic hazard levels and soil classes, within the framework of the Turkish Building Earthquake Code (TBEC 2018). The assessment was conducted in two stages. First, keeping the site class constant, multiple locations characterized by different seismic hazard levels are examined. Second, a fixed geographical location is considered to evaluate the influence of different site classes on isolator response. The performance of the isolation systems is evaluated in terms of displacement demand, base shear ratio, and code-based verification criteria. Additional sensitivity checks were performed using selected limit values to better understand the response trends under changing hazard and soil parameters. The findings highlight how soil amplification effects and seismic intensity levels influence the relative advantages of LRB and FPSs. The results provide practical insight for the selection of seismic isolation systems in hazard-prone regions, contributing to improved performance-based decision-making in earthquake-resistant design. The isolator parameter choices were set based on average catalogue values provided by manufacturers to make this research an example. As a result of the analysis of the isolators’ performance, it was concluded that the FPS-type isolator performed better as acceleration values increased.