Building circularity performance model: a weighted multi-level assessment framework aligned with ISO standards
Saba Mani, Gayani Karunasena, M. Reza Hosseini, Abid HasanPurpose
This paper proposes the building circularity performance (BCP) model to address fragmentation in existing building circularity assessments, which lack comprehensive coverage of circular economy (CE) aspects, standardized KPI weightings and multi-level evaluation across buildings.
Design/methodology/approach
Using a design science research approach, a holistic and weighted assessment framework spanning five building levels (material, subcomponent, component, system and building) was developed. The BCP integrates 52 validated and weighted key performance indicators (KPIs) covering material flows, waste, energy, water, CO2 emissions and design strategies, aligned with ISO 20887 and ISO 59020. The model was demonstrated through a single case study, and evaluated through an expert focus group, four design scenarios and sensitivity analyses of KPIs and weights.
Findings
Results show that circularity performance improves most through strategies extending building lifespan, promoting modularity and optimizing renewable resource use. The findings reveal that circularity emerges from the interaction of material, environmental and design strategies rather than isolated interventions. Sensitivity analyses confirm that the model is both responsive and robust, with bounded variations in outputs and consistent scenario rankings under input and weight changes.
Originality/value
The novelty of BCP lies in its systematic integration and weighting of multiple KPIs in various CE dimensions through a five-level structure. BCP advances existing approaches by integrating previously overlooked dimensions, including locality, hazardous content, environmental performance and design strategies such as repairability and take-back systems, within a single building assessment framework. It also contributes to the Sustainable Development Goals by supporting climate-resilient, resource-efficient and circular building practices.