AMERICANS AND TAIWANESE: A COMPARISON OF BELIEFS IN AND PREFERENCES FOR ADVANCE DIRECTIVES BY SOCIODEMOGRAPHICS
Yuchi Young, Duan-Rung Chen, Ashley Shayya, Taylor Perre, Virgile Barnes, Thomas O’Grady- Life-span and Life-course Studies
- Health Professions (miscellaneous)
- Health (social science)
Abstract
Introduction
Advance directives (ADs) are legal documents that allow individuals to express their end-of-life wishes. However, cultural differences related to collectivism and family values may impact AD beliefs and preferences. This study compares AD beliefs and preferences between American and Taiwanese adults.
Methods
A survey was used to collect data from adults in the US (n=166) and Taiwan (n=2000) to assess AD beliefs and preferences. Propensity score matching was used to compare the populations, and bivariate analyses were conducted to identify AD-specific differences between the two groups.
Results
Compared to the US, Taiwanese participants were younger (mean age = 45 vs. 50), higher percentage female (80% vs. 63%), and higher percentage married (50% vs. 48%). Taiwanese adults had a higher belief in preparing an AD (89.3% vs. 80.7%; p=0.02) and were more willing to complete one than American adults (85.6% vs. 63.1%; p< 0.01). 59.4% of Taiwanese adults preferred their family/loved ones make healthcare decisions, compared to 46.0% of Americans (p=0.01). However, only 50.8% of Taiwanese adults believed their loved ones’ decisions aligned with their wishes, while 79.5% of Americans held this belief (p< 0.001).
Conclusion
This study reveals noteworthy differences in AD beliefs and preferences between the two groups, with Taiwanese adults valuing AD preparation more and being more willing to complete them. Taiwanese adults also rely on their loved ones to make AD decisions, even though they believe these wishes may not align with their own. These differences likely stem from cultural norms of filial piety and collectivism in Taiwan.