A Review of Stroboscopic and Phantom Array Effects in Light-Emitting Diode Lighting

The stroboscopic effect and phantom array effect caused by temporal light modulation (TLM) in light-emitting diode (LED) lighting are important temporal light artifacts (TLAs) that can influence visual perception, task performance, and visual comfort. This review systematically analyzes 40 studies published between 1998 and 2024 to provide a comprehensive overview of the current understanding of both effects. The reviewed literature covers visibility thresholds, influencing parameters, experimental methodologies, and assessment metrics. The analysis shows that reported visibility thresholds for the stroboscopic effect typically range from 550 to 1000 Hz, whereas thresholds for the phantom array effect may extend to 10–15 kHz, suggesting substantial differences in the underlying perceptual mechanisms. In addition to modulation frequency, modulation depth, waveform, duty cycle, luminance, retinal image motion, and observer factors have been identified as important determinants of visibility. The review further highlights significant methodological differences among studies, including variations in experimental design, stimulus generation, participant characteristics, and psychophysical procedures. Although the stroboscopic visibility measure (SVM) provides a standardized framework for evaluating the stroboscopic effect, no comparably validated metric is currently available for the phantom array effect. The review identifies major knowledge gaps regarding the interaction of influencing parameters and the lack of standardized assessment methods. Future research should focus on establishing unified experimental protocols and developing robust metrics for the phantom array effect to support comprehensive lighting standards that protect visual comfort, well-being, and consumer health.