Experience of patients with restraints in acute care hospitals and the view of their relatives: A qualitative study
Sandra Siegrist‐Dreier, Silvia Thomann, Isabelle Barbezat, Dirk Richter, Kai‐Uwe Schmitt, Sabine Hahn- General Nursing
Abstract
Aim
To describe the experiences of patients and relatives with any form of restraints in somatic acute care hospitals.
Design
Qualitative explorative design.
Methods
Qualitative research methods were used. Participants were recruited through clinical nursing specialists in participating departments of a university hospital between June and August 2020. Individual interviews were conducted and analysed using content analysis.
Results
Four interviews with patients and five interviews with relatives were conducted with a mean duration of 25 min. The following three topics emerged in the analysis as important: What was perceived as restraints, Assessing the experiences of restraint use on a continuum, and Lack of information about restrictive measures. Patients and relatives defined restraint very broadly and assessed the experiences of restraint on a continuum from positive to negative, with a more critical view from patients. Relatives clearly seemed to approve of the use of restraints in acute care hospitals because it provided them with a sense of security. In general, there seemed to be a lack of information about the use of restraint and its effects on patients and relatives alike.
Conclusion
The involvement of patients and relatives in the decision‐making process about restraint use seems to be low. Healthcare professionals need to be better educated to be able to pass on adequate information and to involve patients and their relatives adequately in all processes of restraint use. However, when relatives are involved in decision‐making as proxies for patients, it is important to consider that patients' and relatives' opinions on restraints may differ.
Patient or Public Contribution
Patients and relatives agreed to participate in the study and shared their experiences with us.